First of all here is a recording by @DerrickStorm showing all the encounter from start to finish.
We were internal roleplaying before he showed up and we kept roleplaying with him for the duration of the encounter as we were moving him to the camp. I don't know where you got the idea that chat logs show the RP that went down but they don't. Now, of course, we were going to continue RPing with the hostage and give him stellar roleplay, however, we can't really act like he is hiding in plain sight and talk to the wall in front of us. Nor can we talk much about the situation that is happening because he is not there to react to it and hear it as he would normally do would it not have been for the server crash.
Don't get me wrong Jim but you don't seem quite involved in this situation to begin with. In the 2 liner POV, you state that when you got to the camp the situation was over. So not sure what information are you bringing to this report that is relevant other than accusations that have no base behind them.
I don't think you understand what a False Report is, Jim. A false report means that the person filing the report is purposely leaving out information about the events that occurred or straight up lying about it in order to get people banned. Moreover, it can be used when people abuse grey areas from the rules and using them as armour. None of those things happened here. We believe that there were no Defense rights shared as you guys were not in a dynamic group and we believed that the AOGM rule was broken for reasons already stated above. Anyone has a right to report if they feel like a rule was broken. What you are implying is that everyone that reports people for not being in a dynamic is now guilty of a false report, which makes 0 sense because why would you have that rule in place, to begin with.
Moving over to the logs:
19:17:25 | Raul Mendez connected
19:17:55 | Javier Garcia disconnected
19:21:38 | Javier Garcia connected
19:29:48 : Global: Jiri Lanik: Ahoj
As stated in the POV apparently the hostage meets with G19 and Scar at Pogorevka. If this is the case then the meeting must have happened after G19 logged back into the server. So even in the best situation, you guys met with Raul at around 19:22:00. We met him at 19:30:00 as shown by the chat logs. This gives a timeframe of 8 minutes between you guys roleplaying with him and him meeting us. If we take the 5 minutes that it would take for him to go to GM we are now left with barely 3 minutes of you guys meeting up. In this encounter with him, you tell him you have no gear for him and told him to go to Zeleno. This does not sound like a dynamic group at all. If I walk down the street and say hi to someone and then 10 minutes later he gets initiated on in another town that does not give me KOS rights. You met up with a guy, told him to go to Zeleno, 10 minutes later I initiate on him.
Personally, I don't mind you guys showing up, if anything it would have created a cool situation. But the way you guys just rush to kill with barely any interaction with the hostage and right after a restart leaves a pretty bad taste in our mouth. Scar even saw Terra just stand there still and went straight to shooting.
19:47:10 | Branka Hnat connected
[2018/12/11 19:48:03]: (Branka Hnat) hit by (Ricardo Garcia) to LeftArm with Bullet_556x45
Terra connects at 19:47:10 which would mean that she spawns in at around 19:47:30. After 30 seconds she gets gunned down out of nowhere.