Hello so my POV is as follows:
While this situation may look bad on my part and my group at the time of this IC'ly it made complete sense to kill Ming maybe not OOC'ly. So to set the stage me and my guys were rolling around earlier today and came across Ming in Kabinino we talked to him for a good while before taking him hostage on the grounds of being a CDF sympathizer. With one of the goals of our group being to cause civil unrest in the nation and hatred among the local populace for their government. Which something that is not mentioned in this report and one way I would call the BadRP void is that about 20 minutes maybe 30 before this happened we provided Ming with at least 30 minutes of RP probably stretching closer to 40. After extensive interrogation of Ming we let him come into the street and had a fist fight with one of our men and after the fight he ran away while the others were trying to revive @tosstheball. If he was let go I'm not sure I was alt-tabbed out at the time but it was my impression that he ran away.
So after our first encounter with Ming we were hanging around the triangle and we received IC Intel that someone we weren't sure who was in Lopatino talking to the Free Territory about us "Giving them info on us" were the words used in game so naturally with us being allied with FT we went to go talk to them. However this was not our only reason for coming to Lopatino we had also gotten a radio transmission from FT that their base was about to be under attack so this was the main reason we came was to help them. Once we made it to Lopatino we talked with FT and they said yes a man did come and talk to them and said to them something along the lines of "are you one of the FT commie scum" or something like that claiming we asked him that in the interrogation which is completely false. Then after everything unfolds turns out the guy who talked to FT was Ming the person we just help up in Kab for being a CDF sympathizer and who had already received extensive RP 20 or so minutes prior to this second engagement. Now we found him in Lopatino and this time he was armed again, spreading lies to our allies about us (I can only assume in an attempt to break our ties with them as Ming was previously in FT), possibly running away from being captive earlier, and still being a CDF sympathizer. So with all of the evidence staked against him we took Ming hostage once more and moved him to the church.
Now this is the incident on why the report was made which I myself can agree as I already spoke with @Ming formally apologized and told him the RP he received in the church was very poor and should have been carried on a bit longer but I also explained to him why it was not which is what I will do now. So as I've stated earlier we had already given Ming extensive RP and what I would consider to be good RP as well. As we moved into the church we instructed Ming not to talk and he continued too once inside which was why I beat him. Once he started talking back to me I shot him and I understand this in itself is BadRP but if you consider the facts of what happened earlier I would say that BadRP is invalid because we RP'd with Ming for a while. The reason why I killed him so fast was because of the earlier intel that Lop was about to be under attack by an unknown group of people which turned out to be Ming's Dynamic so I was not trying to get all of my men caught out in the wide open of the church with a hostage in a fight it would surely be a death sentence for everyone in there. So in my mind as everything was starting to fall apart and the attack was beginning I shot him so the rest of my men could get back to the safety of the compound and not be caught in the wide open with a hostage who was a member of the attacking group. Finally as I stated at the very beginning of this POV I may not have had OOC rights to kill Ming but I sure did have IC reasons to execute him and for me personally I take IC before OOC if it doesn't make sense to do it IC then I'm not gonna do it because in my mind that's BadRP.
Something else I would like to point out is that this very situation is an outlying occurrence in our group and not a reflection of our style of RP, if you were to speak with almost anyone who has come into contact with us IC'ly they can tell you that we as a group provide extensive and excellent RP. Me personally since I am one of the leaders of the group I'm usually leading the RP and so that gives me only more examples of good RP because chances are if people run into us I'm talking to them and overall I would say we have had WAY more good RP encounters than we have bad ones like this and I would go as far as to call it a slip-up on my part. During my time at DayzRP I have never received a single warning point and I have always tried to steer clear of trouble and as far as this situation goes I'm sorry it ended the way it did @Ming but perhaps you can at least see why I did what I did.
Last but not least a final note on the re-logging situation, as stated earlier by @tosstheball I lag out of the game constantly and get kicked for BE Client not responding so I can assure you it was not combat logging. As for why it took me so long to re-log well for some reason DayzSA HATES my computer and almost everytime I get kicked from the server my entire game freezes and goes in-responsive so I have to open a task manager, close the game and the launcher like that, then re-open the dayz launcher in steam and then launch the game again, find the server and reconnect.