S1 - NVFL / Metagaming - 18/04/2020

[Jackfish]

Server and location: S1 Chernarus, Zelenogorsk

Approximate time and date of the incident (SERVER TIME): 18/04/2020, 23:27 GMT+2

Your in game name: Jaknov Petrov

Names of allies involved: @Rutkiy, @Lucas, @Guigsy

Name of suspect/s: Corp?

Friendly/Enemy vehicles involved (if any): 

Additional evidence? (video/screenshot): 

 

Detailed description of the events: So me and the boys ran around Zelenogorsk, making sure noone was breaking the law. Eventually we heard shots so we decided to take a look. One of our men found a man hiding in a house. He was crying and begging for us to leave. I told him that we weren't going to leave and that he had to come out. He asked me if he could have 5 minutes so I agreed. While I waited infront of the door @Guigsy saw the man jumping out of the window and running away. We started to chase him and eventually got to him. Instead of stopping he continued to run, leaving us no other choice then to initiate. Instead of complying since he was heavily outnumbered he decided to turn around and tried to kill us. It did not work and he got sent to the respawn screen.

An hour or so later @Lucas got killed by a unknown man. We ran up to his body and noticed a random person sitting inside of a industrial building just outside of the millitary base in Zelenogorsk. When I asked the man why he killed my soldier he said "You killed my brother!". We had no clue how he knew who killed his brother and how he knew his brother died, since we took care of the body ASAP. We think the man we killed first, told his friend when he died.

@Guigsy threw a granade in the building and killed the man.

//If the accused PKed his character then I will close this reporr.

Edited April 19, 2020 by Jackfish

[boring]

Laskei Orlovsky POV:

Hello roleplayers! so basically S-GRU Unit was doing the usual weapons check in zelenogorsk, trying to find people who are in violation of directive 4.7 where we hear a bunch of shots go off around the military base area and so we all ran to the shots to then see a man run into a building and head to the top floor and close himself in with his gun, @Jackfish proceeded to converse to the man and the man was histerical. Scared of the gun shots or some shit like that and asks for 5 mins himself to which we allow, immediately he jumps from top floor balcony (rip ankles) and legs it to another nearby house to which we surround as shown in the video. we had enough of it and so @Rutkiy initiates on the man to which he turns around and attempts to gun down 4 S-GRU Soldiers with his M417.

Roughly about an hour or so later @Lucas is in zeleno military base to which he is instantly KOS'D, we were all nearby and run to the shots to which we find his body.. we then notice a man inside of the industrial building who is shouting something like "you killed my brother so how do you like that" Im not entirely sure how he got information that we killed the man earlier which is suspect hence he is being reported for metagaming. We put two and two together and figure out he was friends with the first man that perished. Not sure if in approved group or not neither. I then unpin my trusty nade and YEET it into the window, The man dies a death and the end

This is the video evidence i have: 

 

 

 

 

[Eddie]

Connection logs:

Spoiler

19:17:11 | Player "Jaknov Petrov" is connected
21:28:57 | Player "Jaknov Petrov" has been disconnected
21:29:09 | Player "Jaknov Petrov" is connected
23:18:18 | Player "Jaknov Petrov" has been disconnected
23:20:37 | Player "Jaknov Petrov" is connected
01:41:16 | Player "Jaknov Petrov" has been disconnected

19:17:15 | Player "Laskei Orlovsky" is connected
23:18:18 | Player "Laskei Orlovsky" has been disconnected
23:21:58 | Player "Laskei Orlovsky" is connected
01:40:44 | Player "Laskei Orlovsky" has been disconnected

19:57:15 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" is connected
21:29:01 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" has been disconnected
21:29:09 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" is connected
21:46:05 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" has been disconnected
21:47:31 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" is connected
21:59:36 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" has been disconnected

19:30:33 | Player "Andrei Smirnov" is connected
21:30:54 | Player "Andrei Smirnov" has been disconnected
21:31:01 | Player "Andrei Smirnov" is connected
23:18:18 | Player "Andrei Smirnov" has been disconnected
23:21:39 | Player "Andrei Smirnov" is connected
00:01:12 | Player "Andrei Smirnov" has been disconnected

18:34:40 | Player "Eli Jones" is connected
19:14:24 | Player "Eli Jones" has been disconnected
21:07:36 | Player "Eli Jones" is connected
21:39:17 | Player "Eli Jones" has been disconnected
21:58:20 | Player "Eli Jones" is connected
23:18:18 | Player "Eli Jones" has been disconnected

18:09:13 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" is connected
19:05:43 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" has been disconnected
21:04:02 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" is connected
21:29:21 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" has been disconnected
21:29:53 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" is connected
21:32:14 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" has been disconnected
22:42:53 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" is connected
22:43:03 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" has been disconnected

Hit logs:

Spoiler

21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.6, 206.5>) hit by Player "Jaknov Petrov" (pos=<2722.9, 5314.6, 206.5>) with AKM from 13.0521 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.8, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Jaknov Petrov" (pos=<2723, 5314.6, 206.5>) with AKM from 12.9515 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2736.1, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Jaknov Petrov" (pos=<2722.9, 5314.3, 206.5>) with AKM from 13.2243 meters 

21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.6, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2730.5, 5308.6, 206.5>) with AKM from 7.38041 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.5, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2730.7, 5308.6, 206.5>) with AKM from 7.18179 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.5, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2730.7, 5308.6, 206.5>) with AKM from 7.18179 meters
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2730.9, 5308.7, 206.5>) with AKM from 6.88071 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2730.9, 5308.7, 206.5>) with AKM from 6.88071 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2736.2, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2731.0, 5308.7, 206.5>) with AKM from 6.96847 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2736.2, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2731.0, 5308.7, 206.5>) with AKM from 6.96847 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2736.2, 5313.5, 206.5>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2731.3, 5309.0, 206.5>) with AKM from 6.6795 meters 

21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.8, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" (pos=<2726.7, 5316.0, 206.5>) with AKM from 9.53867 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2736.2, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" (pos=<2726.6, 5315.6, 206.5>) with AKM from 9.82164 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2736.2, 5313.4, 206.5>) hit by Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" (pos=<2726.6, 5315.5, 206.5>) with AKM from 9.85797 meters

21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.6, 206.5>) hit by Player "Andrei Smirnov" (pos=<2726.5, 5309.0, 206.5>) with AKM from 10.4876 meters 
21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2735.9, 5313.6, 206.5>) hit by Player "Andrei Smirnov" (pos=<2726.5, 5309.0, 206.5>) with AKM from 10.4876 meters 
21:26:42 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2736.5, 5313.5, 206.5>) hit by Player "Andrei Smirnov" (pos=<2727.7, 5308.6, 206.5>) with AKM from 10.0331 meters 
21:26:42 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2737.0, 5313.5, 206.5>) hit by Player "Andrei Smirnov" (pos=<2728.2, 5308.5, 206.5>) with AKM from 10.1213 meters 
21:26:42 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<2737.0, 5313.5, 206.5>) hit by Player "Andrei Smirnov" (pos=<2728.2, 5308.5, 206.5>) with AKM from 10.1213 meters 
21:27:09 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (pos=<5422.0, 4589.4, 237.2>) hit by is unconscious

21:36:49 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" (pos=<2522.8, 5127.0, 193.4>) hit by Player "Eli Jones" (pos=<2521.0, 5134.5, 193.5>) with Wolf AR15 from 7.69023 meters 
21:36:50 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" (pos=<2524.0, 5126.1, 193.4>) hit by Player "Eli Jones" (pos=<2520.8, 5134.5, 193.5>) with Wolf AR15 from 8.91498 meters 

21:39:07 | Player "Eli Jones" (pos=<2525.2, 5134.2, 197.1>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2523.8, 5123.4, 193.2>) with M67Grenade_Ammo into (-1) for 49.2518 damage (M67Grenade_Ammo)
21:39:13 | Player "Eli Jones" (pos=<2525.1, 5133.0, 193.4>) hit by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2524.5, 5131.0, 193.3>) with AKM from 2.09755 meters 

Kill logs:

Spoiler

21:26:41 | Player "Thomas Rutherford" (DEAD) (pos=<2735.9, 5313.6, 206.5>) killed by Player "Andrei Smirnov" (pos=<2726.5, 5309.0, 206.5>) with AKM from 10.4876 meters 

21:36:49 | Player "Aleksandr Cheznov" (DEAD) (pos=<2522.8, 5127.0, 193.4>) killed by Player "Eli Jones" (pos=<2521.0, 5134.5, 193.5>) with Wolf AR15 from 7.69023 meters 

21:39:07 | Player "Eli Jones" (DEAD) (pos=<2525.2, 5134.2, 197.1>) killed by Player "Laskei Orlovsky" (pos=<2523.8, 5123.4, 193.2>) with 6-M7 Frag Grenade

Chat logs:

Spoiler

21:16:58 | Chat("Jaknov Petrov"): *Opens the mans backpack*
21:17:17 | Chat("Jaknov Petrov"): *Searches his supplies*
21:17:53 | Chat("Jaknov Petrov"): *Opens his bacpack*
21:18:06 | Chat("Jaknov Petrov"): *opens his backpack*

Calling in the following people for their full POV and any unedited video evidence they may have. Also if there is anyone else involved in this situation, please list them.

@Jackfish | Jaknov Petrov | OP

@Rutkiy | Andrei Smirnov | POSTED

@Lucas | Aleksandr Cheznov | POSTED

@Guigsy | Laskei Orlovsky | POSTED

@TheMcgregor | Eli Jones | POSTED

@RUDDY | Thomas Rutherford | POSTED

[TheMcgregor]

Good morning.

 

3 hours ago, Jackfish said:

Server and location: S1 Chernarus, Zelenogorsk

Approximate time and date of the incident (SERVER TIME): 18/04/2020, 23:27 GMT+2

Your in game name: Jaknov Petrov

Names of allies involved: @Rutkiy, @Lucas, @Guigsy

Name of suspect/s: Corp?

Friendly/Enemy vehicles involved (if any): 

Additional evidence? (video/screenshot): Video will be posted tomorrow

Detailed description of the events: So me and the boys ran around Zelenogorsk, making sure noone was breaking the law. Eventually we heard shots so we decided to take a look. One of our men found a man hiding in a house. He was crying and begging for us to leave. I told him that we weren't going to leave and that he had to come out. He asked me if he could have 5 minutes so I agreed. While I waited infront of the door @Guigsy saw the man jumping out of the window and running away. We started to chase him and eventually got to him. Instead of stopping he continued to run, leaving us no other choice then to initiate. Instead of complying since he was heavily outnumbered he decided to turn around and tried to kill us. It did not work and he got sent to the respawn screen.

An hour or so later @Lucas got killed by a unknown man. We ran up to his body and noticed a random person sitting inside of a industrial building just outside of the millitary base in Zelenogorsk. When I asked the man why he killed my soldier he said "You killed my brother!". We had no clue how he knew who killed his brother and how he knew his brother died, since we took care of the body ASAP. We think the man we killed first, told his friend when he died.

@Guigsy threw a granade in the building and killed the man.

//If the accused PKed his character then I will close this reporr.

Most of what the OP said is pretty accurate HOWEVER a few parts are not and this is fact.

 

the stand off with OP and my group member Thomas Rutherford lasted a good 10 minutes+ as opposed to what the initial video evidence shows. Upon making initial contact with the OP Thomas Rutherford was talking to a few men near the redwood radio station when he clearly shouted out and I repeat ‘omg it’s the f******g Russians’ and this was heard on the radio and I am sure if called upon the people who were with him can second this. I believe Thomas Rutherford ran away from the men in question as he had weapons on him he shouldn’t have however he got into trouble with some infected and had to run into a building hence why he was trapped and backed into a corner. I heard Thomas Rutherford pleading with the Russians for 5+ minutes to leave him alone and during this time he was saying things like and I quote “I know you will take my weapons off me it’s what you do” or something along them lines and I could hear the Russian accents over the radio. - ask the OP for the unedited video and this will prove everything I am saying.

 

 I was on the server in Zelenogorsk roughly about 200-300m away from the entire incident, I could hear on the radio everything that was going on - they never at any point held him up or took his radio off him - and all a sudden the radio goes dead after hearing the shots and I get no response from my fellow operative. Also I may add it was not over an hour later it was a max of about 15 minutes when I shot the man and the logs will show that so surely that is lying in a report?. I knew it was a member of the Russians who I shot and shot my fellow group member because I have been held up by them previously and I know they all wear red berets and patrol Zelenogorsk more than any other city.

 

This is not metagaming or NVFL on my part and to backup my side of events I would ask the OP post the entire initial incident with Thomas Rutherford which certainly lasted more than the 30 seconds of footage posted. To add to this the conversation I had with the OP or whoever the person was outside the building hasn’t been posted which included the part where he infact asked ‘why did you kill my brother’ to which I explained I was on the radio to my friend the entire time before everything went quiet and I also heard everything through it. I did not simply kos I heard the man talking to me, I could see him out of the window with his red beret, I could hear him talking to me in a Russian accent and this is how I came to the conclusion he was Russian. I was behind a thick wall with plenty of cover. I did not want to make my presence known to the Russians however I was seen apparently because that is what one of them stated “I can see you in there with your head mask” or something like that and this has not been posted by the OP for some reason? I was not going to fire until the man confronted me to which I felt I was backed into a corner and had to do something.
 

I have never been in a report previously and killing people is not something I do often as I do not make a habit of it. I would ask the fact I am a ‘whitename’ does not automatically mean what the OP is saying is true.

 

Everything I have said is facts and I would ask again that the OP post the full 5-10 minute video of his initial contact with Thomas Rutherford - in which I heard everything that was going on - along with this their initial arrival in Zeleno in which they caught Thomas Rutherford running off. Also please post the unedited version of their initial contact with me in the building which lasted alot longer than the video shows.

 

Can I also ask why in the second video you can clearly hear people talking separately rather than in game? Is this allowed? talking out of character then in character and using it to their own advantage so I couldn't hear them?

 

Thanks for taking the time to read, I apologize for this incident in taking up your time also but I must reject the claim of metagaming on my behalf.

also Thomas Rutherford has pk'd his character as a result of this and I believe he deleted the character already. I do not want any further action taken against the OP or any of the group involved. I love playing on these servers and want to continue to do so to the best of my ability I would have happily talked this out on discord if requested, for me the whole thing has been forgotten as I have already been back on the server after these events and continued with my dayzRP experience which I enjoy profusely.

 

Lastly I am willing to PK MY character as long as the character I killed is PK'd along with him. That is all I have to say I will only respond if asked or required to do so by a moderator and/or admin.

Edited April 19, 2020 by TheMcgregor

[Jackfish]

If he did PK his character then im willing to drop this report.

[RUDDY]

The character was deleted. I made a new one, so yeah, the character was perma-killed.

[RUDDY]

Can I also point out the fact that you lads knew fine well that I had perma'd my character? I informed Jackfish well before this report was thrown up. It seems you posted it in order to embarrass or ridicule me. Can I also ask why you said it was roughly "an hour later" when the logs prove it was around 10 minutes after the initial incident?

[Jackfish]

I talked with @RUDDY on discord. He indeed sent me a message saying he permad his character yesterday. I missed his message.

[TheMcgregor]

All is resolved. Thank you.

 

PS could I please just ask a moderator/admin to scan over the report and just give a hypothetical verdict whether it would have been deemed metagaming or not? Obviously I do not believe it was but I just like reassurance for my own peace of mind going forward to ensure I am not doing anything I shouldn't be and to learn from it if need be. Thanks.

Edited April 19, 2020 by TheMcgregor

[Inferno]

After looking through what is currently given, the staff team has decided to keep the report up. We still require @Rutkiy, @RUDDY and @Lucas for their POVs and any videos they may have.

[Para]

7 hours ago, RUDDY said:

The character was deleted. I made a new one, so yeah, the character was perma-killed.

Out of curiosity,

What made you want to PK the character off to the point where he'd do something so foolish like that? I see you're still in the same group so why the sudden change in character?

Please answer these questions in addition to providing your POV. Thank you.

[Rutkiy]

Andrei Smirnov POV: While RPing in Zeleno, one of the lads says there's a guy in a house trying to avoid us. Eventually he jumps out of the window and attempts to flee. We run after him and after like a minute or two, I decide to initiate, and my other group mates follow my lead. The guy non-complies and is put down. Later, we hear more shots and, I believe, @Jackfish notices that @Lucas is dead by one of the garages near Zelenogorsk military. There's a guy on the 2nd floor who had killed Lucas. @Guigsy throws the nade up to him, and he falls dead on the floor.

Edited April 19, 2020 by Rutkiy

[Lucas]

Aleksandr Cheznov POV: 

We notice gunshots in town and head towards them as I get there, I notice loads of zombies so I begin to clear them out. I notice someones inside and begin talking to him and notice he has an illegal firearm. As time passes he begins to just tell us "Give me a minute" or something along the lines of that. We notice that he's just attempting to avoid the situation completely just to save his weapon. After some talking, we notice the man has jumped out of the window and I begin to follow him. I talk to him as he's running away and block him into a house he leaves the other side and we initiate on him. He decides to not comply even though it's 4v1 and we kill him. After a certain amount of time we hear more gunshots down the road and I head towards them, I notice someone inside a building so I attempt to talk to him. He doesn't answer for a few minutes and then I'm shot out of no where.

[RUDDY]

3 hours ago, Para said:

Out of curiosity,

What made you want to PK the character off to the point where he'd do something so foolish like that? I see you're still in the same group so why the sudden change in character?

Please answer these questions in addition to providing your POV. Thank you.

Because I was told by the OP that a report wouldn't go up if I was to PK my character. The situation itself was shit, and I deeply regret what happened.

 

So, I was inside a house and zombies were agro'd on me. I had holed up and the Russians were beneath me clearing out the infected. One saw me with my AKM. From the point of me at the Radio station, I had my own radio on the full time. I spoke with people and went "Oh shit it's the Russians" and I ran, thats when the zombies agro'd on me. I didn't want to lose my weapon, so I attempted to run away and get out of the situation. At this point, I had my weapon in my hand and spun to look at them, while spinning I aimed the weapon upwards which wasn't the best decision but it was an instinct from myself, a stupid one at that. All in all, I PKed my character because of the report and the sheer stupidity shown by myself and my character, and he deserved a perma-kill for what happened.

2 hours ago, Rutkiy said:

Andrei Smirnov POV: While RPing in Zeleno, one of the lads says there's a guy in a house trying to avoid us. Eventually he jumps out of the window and attempts to flee. We run after him and after like a minute or two, I decide to initiate, and my other group mates follow my lead. The guy non-complies and is put down. Later, we hear more shots and, I believe, @Jackfish notices that @Lucas is dead by one of the garages near Zelenogorsk military. There's a guy on the 2nd floor who had killed Lucas. @Guigsy throws the nade up to him, and he falls dead on the floor.

Can I also point out that it wasn't a minute or two of running? It was around 20 seconds from me jumping from that window and running and you initiating.

 

 

The evidence provided by those who put this report up also show members actively metagaming through discord. "Jack back off, Jack back off away from the fucking door!". My friend McGregor would have more than likely heard this, and been able to divert himself if he heard "I'm gonna throw a fucking grenade", which wasn't double-microphoned into the game as well as discord.

Edited April 19, 2020 by RUDDY

[Rutkiy]

14 minutes ago, RUDDY said:

Can I also point out that it wasn't a minute or two of running? It was around 20 seconds from me jumping from that window and running and you initiating.

Sorry mate, wasn't counting the seconds from when you jumped from the window, my bad, I was just giving a rough time

[RUDDY]

Just now, Rutkiy said:

Sorry mate, wasn't counting the seconds from when you jumped from the window, my bad, I was just giving a rough time

You have given a rough time two times now. Once in the first instance where you lied about it being roughly an hour when my friend killed you and then now, where you stated it was one-two minutes. If you could, could one of you post unedited footage of the second video of the "meta-gaming" claims? Can I also ask yourselves why you quite clearly broke the rule under 3.6 where it states "While in presence of other players all such communication should also be transmitted in game using "double mic" mechanic. This means transmitting both through in game VOIP and external software simultaneously" ?

[Para]

So I have a question

@Jackfish,

When talking to this guy, what exactly did you offer? Did you say "I will drop the report if you PK your character" like @TheMcgregor seems to claim?

[Jackfish]

3 minutes ago, Para said:

So I have a question

@Jackfish,

When talking to this guy, what exactly did you offer? Did you say "I will drop the report if you PK your character" like @TheMcgregor seems to claim?

Like I also told him, I did not read his last reply, I wouldnt of reported it if I saw it. This was also the second time the accused was involved in a NVFL situation. We talked the first one out. Thats why I said 'once again'  

Spoiler

 

Edited April 19, 2020 by Jackfish

[RUDDY]

Last point here, sorry to add on. But the OP's actions here and those on their side who has replied hasn't made me feel the best. 

1) They claim McGregor took around 1 hour to kill them after the initial incident. The logs prove they were lying, and although they may claim that their time-frames were rough, how do you get 10 minutes and 1 hour mixed up?

2) They claimed that they took 1-2 minutes between me jumping out the window and them initiating. They lied about this also.

3) They have quite clearly broke Rule 3.6 which prevents metagaming through external softwares, leading to my friend being killed.

4) Footage provided by those who put this report up has quite clearly been edited and the original footage hasn't been provided. There is no excuse for this, due to the fact they have quite clearly edited times on the videos down to suit their agenda. This is seen through the two different time frames of the videos, 26 seconds and 42 seconds.

[Para]

@Jackfish, @TheMcgregor, @RUDDY,

Firstly thank you both for your quick answers to our questions. 

Upon further review we have chosen to honour the OP's wishes to close the report. Whilst there were rulebreaks in this situation we do not see anything out of the ordinary to warrant keeping this open. You both have reached a common understanding regarding the situation and understood what you did wrong which is what we encourage. That being said, there are a couple of things we would like to address in this situation.

@RUDDY please keep in mind that permanently killing your character is not a foolproof method of escaping NVFL bans in the future. RP is still required to be tasteful, meaningful and actually have depth. Your RP in this situation was arguably sub-par. Killing your character just to avoid a ban will not work in all cases, in fact had this report pursued you would have received punishment for this. You are fortunate that the OP does not wish to continue AND that we have decided to close this.

@Jackfish, you and another member in your videos were not transmitting in game when speaking over the radio. This is a clear violation of our telepathic communication rule and would've likely seen you both hit for metagaming. Please keep this in mind for the future as we do not wish to see a simple mistake repeated.

Lastly, we do not see sufficient evidence that @TheMcgregor had metagamed. Being in radio contact with someone nearby, followed by radio silence and a hail of gunshots would indeed be in character reasoning to believe somebody had just killed your friend. It was a hunch that was acted on in our eyes, thus we would not have acted on this.

We are happy that both parties could come to common ground and resolve this matter themselves. With that said,

/solved.

Signed by: @Para, @Peril, @Conor and @Eddie.