S1 - Bad RP - Cernaya Polana Appeal

[Sapphire]

Link to the source of punishment (report/post): 

 

I do not dispute the verdict involving BadRP, I know I broke that rule. But I do not believe that it was fair to consider that I was trolling. Yes I was disrupting the experience of those around me, but trolling is done by people with malicious intent. I had none. While I doubtlessly bothered the people present in the report, everyone I've ever seen trolling was very deliberate about it. I argue that what I did was anything but deliberate/malicious. I was trying to be silly, and in doing so I broke the rules. I never wanted to actually upset anyone. 

Additional statements/comments explaining your point of view: There are also some things in the reasoning of the verdict that do not make sense to me. "You had absolutely no interest whatsoever in listening, instead you caused the most disruption as possible with the excessive use of the // prefix, sneezing, attempting to get everyone sick and then afterwards asking for medicine when you supposedly are not there. This is not acceptable and we don’t even know why you would think this would be allowed." As I tried to explain in my POV, I was very interested in what everyone was talking about, which is why I broke the rules and was out there in the first place. I also tried to explain that I was not the only one sick, and that I was not trying to spread it to everyone at all. While at the bottom line I wasn't supposed to be there (which I agree with), I was not trolling in any sense of the word. If I was really trolling, where's my motive to do so? I have none, and it's just not what I was doing.

What would you like to achieve with this appeal: I am hoping to get the trolling verdict taken off of me, which means a lighter ban and less points.

What could you have done better?: I could have been a lot more aware of the fact that what I was doing was against the rules, and I could've kept myself much more refreshed with the rules than I have.

 

One thing I would like to make clear out of all of this, that I am not lying and doing anything I can to try not to be in trouble. I genuinely feel really bad that I did break a rule. While I got Emerald, I'm still a very new player to the server and all I've tried to do is have good RP with others. Thank you.

[EaglesBR]

Hello @Sapphire

A separate team of staff have reviewed your appeal and come to the conclusion to DENY it.

The roleplay you displayed was nothing short of abysmal in this situation, everyone involved was trying to have a serious conversation about things that have been taking place within the server and instead of providing any substance to the conversation at hand you go out of your way to try and make others sick while also typing in OOC chat numerous times saying you weren't IC. While you may not view what you did as trolling that is exactly what it is. In the future I would suggest that if you aren't going to contribute to what is going on around you to remove yourself from the area so as to avoid something like this again.

The original verdict however was incorrect in the punishment you received. Therefore it will be altered. The Trolling outcome will remain while the BadRP portion will be removed.

 

Appeal Denied, Report verdict changed.

 

Signed @Eagles @Hofer @JobScholten