Sapphire boring Posted February 5, 2020 Sapphire Share Posted February 5, 2020 Link to the source of punishment (report/post): Why the verdict is not fair: Yes, i did give lucas info in the video which i had posted, but then after that he came to the warehouse and i gave him the information IN CHARACTER, he never used the knowledge given until he came to me and i gave it to him in character, which is not metagaming.. but now im on a final warning because of this? if lucas had just avoided the warehouse then yeah it would've been metagaming, however it was not, i gave him info OOCLY about the guy, then his character rushes (with ben) to me to ask about it, and to which i give info of where the man went... regardless of when i said it (on that very second or literally 10 seconds later or so), his character was given IN GAME info about the man who was in the warehouse. Additional statements/comments explaining your point of view: I really really do fail to understand what i lied about too? i had asked for this to be taken down because i did not want to see a new player get banned, and i would've rather had him prosper into the community, grasp roleplay and stay with us at DayZRP.com, i then said although he did clearly place the landmine with malicious intent, i was willing to let it slip and if the staff wanted to do something about it then that was fine, so i delete the main video and keep up the two clips of me encountering the man, and us destroying the landmine which is enough evidence for the staff team to come to a reasonable verdict against the accused not me, all they missed out was the accused walking away and me saying to lucas oocly what was going on, and to which i gave the info ICly about 10-30 seconds later after he came to the warehosue after i alluded that someone was snooping around. "For that reason we believe you maliciously and intentionally decided to tamper with and remove evidence. There was a reason why we asked you to post the full video; in the full video you can be seen metagaming with people over discord. After further review, we have found you guilty of lying about this in this report by saying that: “deleted from my youtube the video was, as well from my hardrive to clear up space”. Later in DMs with @Conor you admit to “straightup deleting it”." - How is there malicious intent? you guys literally admit that its an assumption that i did it, when i clearly did not. i would also like to know what i "lied" about in this report? how can i lie about deleting something from youtube when literally the screenshots were posted to prove that i did? i deleted it just after i asked for the case to be closed for the reason i had already said, not because i was guilty of metagaming? which i am not. and what if i "admitted" to connor that i "straight up deleted it"? i had already said that on the OP saying i deleted it from youtube and removed it from my harddrive as i borderline have little space What would you like to achieve with this appeal: Final warning to be lifted, as well as the 10 day ban. What could you have done better?: I could've kept the video uploaded to youtube for the staff team to come to a reasonable verdict, however i had already made two videos prior (to which i kept up) that were relevent to the accused wrong doings, as i have already said all they missed out was the accused walking away from the situation and me speaking over discord to lucas about who it was (OOCLY) which was info not used icly until he came to me in the warehouse, to which i said the direction the man went. here is also the full convo with Connor. Link to comment
Legend PublicVoodoo Posted February 5, 2020 Legend Share Posted February 5, 2020 Ok we are reviewing this case as discussed on discord. Firstly though a question: 1. Did you delete the video from youtube yourself? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixkZspDtTwU&feature=youtu.be For some reason the link shows up as the video being set to private yet looking at the screenshots you sent to @Conor this video is nowhere in the playlist. Id imagine you would have done this yourself as youtube would not delete a video unless there was significant reason to do so and they would also email you should a removal take place. Im just asking to get it confirmed as to what actually happened with the video evidence. Link to comment
Sapphire boring Posted February 5, 2020 Author Sapphire Share Posted February 5, 2020 I removed the video myself not long after i put the request for it to go down due to the said reason (accused being new to server and whatnot), the video is not on private or anything like that it is upright removed.this is what comes up for me, and as shown in the screenshots sent to connor, this still persists. Link to comment
Legend Hofer Posted February 6, 2020 Legend Share Posted February 6, 2020 38 minutes ago, speirs said: I removed the video myself not long after i put the request for it to go down due to the said reason (accused being new to server and whatnot), the video is not on private or anything like that it is upright removed.this is what comes up for me, and as shown in the screenshots sent to connor, this still persists. The URL in your screenshot does not show the same URL as @Voodoo linked earlier here. Link to comment
Sapphire boring Posted February 6, 2020 Author Sapphire Share Posted February 6, 2020 (edited) thats just the browser i use doing it, Opera GX. here is a screenshot. // proof Edited February 6, 2020 by speirs Link to comment
Diamond RandyRP Posted February 9, 2020 Diamond Share Posted February 9, 2020 Greetings @speirs, The Admin Team have reviewed this appeal and come to the final conclusion. After looking over everything that was laid out to us, the original report, and discussing it multiple times we have decided to remove your Final Warning and issue you 10 Warning Points for the rulebreaks in the original report. Then original Ban will remain which was set to 10 days. With that said you asked for the report to be closed which you have the right to do so, but it is up to the GM Team if they want to honor your request or deny it and keep the report open. Therefore, in the future please keep all video evidence until the report is closed by the GM Team, this includes evidence saved on your computer or evidence that has already been uploaded to YouTube. This will help avoid the issue of evidence being deleted when the GM Team decide to keep a report open. We do not want this situation to happen again in the future. With that said the following will stand: @speirs - Lying in a report / Metagaming | Guilty - 10 Warning Points & Ban Remains Signed by: @Voodoo, @Saunders, & @Randy Link to comment
Recommended Posts