S2 Livonia: Griefing in Topolin - 02/01/2020 (21-23 PM)

[Duplessis]

Server and location: S2 Livonia, Topolin

Approximate time and date of the incident (SERVER TIME): Between 21:00 and 23:00

Your in game name: Valery Kuznetsov

Names of allies involved: N/A

Name of suspect/s: N/A

Friendly/Enemy vehicles involved (if any): Unknown

Additional evidence? (video/screenshot): 

Detailed description of the events: I went out of town to visit the Soup Kitchen in Sitnik. On the way there I found a car. When I drove back, I returned to our gate being open. I parked the car and went inside to find stuff on the floor with adequate space in the barrels to put it back in. There was also a water barrel stand left outside our base but I do not have photographs of that. I am unsure as to when this took place, only that they sawed off the lock to raid us. Then, when I parked the car and went to find a lock, they returned and took the car again (I assume) as it was gone.

[Conor]

Connection Logs:

Spoiler

19:56:21 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" is connected
22:12:01 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" has been disconnected

20:18:04 | Player "Joel Miller" is connected
00:33:09 | Player "Joel Miller" has been disconnected

 

Position Logs:

Spoiler

21:32:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<11351.1, 10051, 171.8>)
21:37:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<11347.3, 10058.1, 171.9>)
21:42:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<11331.2, 10042.6, 172.3>)
21:47:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<10939.6, 10649.9, 184.2>)
21:52:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<10651, 11054.8, 180.4>)
21:57:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<11219.1, 10304.9, 174.3>)
22:02:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<10898.9, 10738.8, 184.7>)
22:07:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<10775.7, 10868.6, 186.5>)
22:17:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<11335.4, 10033.3, 172.5>)
22:22:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<10811.5, 10850.8, 184.5>)
22:27:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<9267.1, 11658.2, 175.0>)
22:32:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<7370.2, 11512.2, 174.7>)
22:37:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<5543.7, 10509.4, 181.7>)
22:42:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<3641.6, 8613.0, 192.0>)
22:47:49 | Player "Valery Kuznetsov" (pos=<1534.7, 7426.2, 184.0>)

21:32:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1482.6, 7394.9, 183.6>)
21:37:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1264.9, 7398.3, 186.5>)
21:42:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1264.9, 7398.3, 186.5>)
21:47:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1273.8, 7370.6, 186.7>)
21:52:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1317.6, 6953.8, 237.9>)
21:57:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1480.8, 6939.2, 250.4>)
22:02:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1552.5, 6934.8, 248.9>)
22:07:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<3168.9, 4949.9, 405.8>)
22:12:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<3085.4, 2579.0, 455.3>)
22:17:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<5088.0, 3388.4, 433.1>)
22:22:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<6558.7, 3958.2, 382.7>)
22:27:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<9379.5, 3376.6, 278.0>)
22:32:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<10754.8, 964.2, 230.1>)
22:37:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<11575.6, 398.2, 213.3>)
22:42:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<11537.3, 417.6, 217.4>)
22:47:49 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<11551.3, 410.3, 213.2>)

 

Construction Logs:

Spoiler

21:40:35 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1264.9, 7398.3, 186.5>) destroyed CodeLock on Fence at <1264.905640, 186.559128, 7398.340332>
21:43:35 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1264.9, 7398.3, 186.5>) destroyed CodeLock on Fence at <1264.905640, 186.559128, 7398.340332>
21:46:34 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1265.3, 7398.6, 186.5>) destroyed CodeLock on Fence at <1265.339355, 186.558868, 7398.690430>
21:47:38 | Player "Joel Miller" (pos=<1273.1, 7372.4, 186.6>) placed Waterbarrel Kit

 

---

Calling in the following people for their point of view as well as any un-edited video evidence they may have.

@CynicalCertainty - Valery Kuznetsov - OP

@JoeRogan - Joel Miller - POSTED

[Guest]

Not sure how it was griefing? I was the one who sawed the lock all of my friends were the ones who were moving stuff out in and inside of barrels, They mainly wanted the barrels i was just sitting there sawing a lock. I'm sure whatever they did they didn't do it. @apaliics can vouch for me.

[Duplessis]

I have spoken with the person mentioned in the report. I am considering closing the report but I would like to discuss with other members of my group first before coming to a final conclusion. Could the report be put on hold?

[Duplessis]

After consulting with the other members of my group, we have decided not to close the report and go ahead with it. With that said we would also like to take the report off hold.

Edited February 2, 2020 by CynicalCertainty

[RandyRP]

Greetings,

After reviewing this report, logs, and evidence that has been provided we have come to the conclusion. We do not see this as griefing, as there are minimal items left on the ground, which could have been dropped for multiple different things. It doesn't seem like it this was done with malicious intent or on purpose, it seems more like there was swapping of items or transferring of items and things might have been dropped. The griefing rule: 

4.8 Griefing is act of damaging or destroying a player base, storage container, vehicles or their contents using OOC knowledge, ill intent or doing so without IC reasoning that is proportionate to the damage done.

With that said the following will stand:

@JoeRogan - Griefing | Not Guilty 

Signed by Myself w/ Notes